For many London businesses, payroll decisions evolve over time. What works when you have one or two employees can start to feel inefficient as the business grows, staff numbers increase, and compliance obligations become more demanding.
At that point, employers often face a practical question: should payroll remain in-house, or is it time to outsource?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both in-house and outsourced payroll have advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your business size, complexity, and available resources. This guide compares the two approaches to help London employers make an informed decision.
Let us dig deeper into in-house vs outsourced payroll:
What Is In-House Payroll?
In-house payroll means payroll is handled internally by you or a member of your team. This may involve:
- Using payroll software
- Managing PAYE and deductions internally
- Submitting Real Time Information (RTI) to HM Revenue & Customs
- Handling pension calculations and statutory payments
In-house payroll is often the starting point for smaller businesses.
What Is Outsourced Payroll?
Outsourced payroll involves engaging a specialist provider to run payroll on your behalf. Depending on the service level, this can range from basic payroll processing to fully managed payroll services.
The provider typically handles:
- Payroll calculations
- Payslips and reporting
- HMRC submissions
- Compliance and legislative updates
Your role is mainly to provide accurate employee information and approve payroll before processing.
Pros of In-House Payroll
Greater Day-to-Day Control
Keeping payroll in-house gives direct visibility over payroll data and processes, which some business owners prefer.
Suitable for Very Small Teams
For businesses with only one or two employees and simple pay structures, in-house payroll can be manageable.
No External Dependency
Payroll isn’t reliant on third-party providers or external timelines.
Cons of In-House Payroll
Time-Consuming
Payroll requires ongoing attention, especially when rules change or staff circumstances vary.
Higher Risk of Errors
Without specialist knowledge, mistakes with tax codes, RTI submissions, or pensions are more likely.
Compliance Responsibility Rests with You
Even if software is used, legal responsibility for payroll compliance remains with the employer.
Vulnerable to Staff Absences
If one person handles payroll, holidays or sickness can disrupt processing.
Pros of Outsourced Payroll
Reduced Administrative Burden
Outsourcing removes the need to manage payroll tasks internally, freeing up time for business priorities.
Improved Accuracy and Compliance
Specialist providers follow payroll legislation closely, reducing the risk of errors and penalties.
Continuity and Reliability
Payroll continues even during staff absences, busy periods, or business growth.
Access to Payroll Expertise
Support is available when questions arise around tax, pensions, or statutory payments.
Cons of Outsourced Payroll
Less Hands-On Control
Some employers prefer to keep all payroll processes internal.
Ongoing Cost
Outsourced payroll involves a regular fee, although this often offsets internal time costs.
Reliance on Timely Information
Payroll accuracy still depends on the employer providing correct and timely data.
In-House vs Outsourced Payroll: Which Is Right for Your London Business?
In-house payroll may suit:
- Very small businesses
- Simple payroll structures
- Employers with in-house payroll expertise
Outsourced payroll may suit:
- Growing SMEs
- Businesses with variable pay or multiple staff
- Employers seeking compliance reassurance
- Businesses looking to reduce admin and risk
For many London businesses, payroll complexity increases faster than expected, making outsourcing a practical long-term solution.
Compliance Considerations for Both Options
Regardless of how payroll is handled, employers remain legally responsible for:
- PAYE accuracy
- RTI submissions
- Pension auto-enrolment
- Statutory payments
Outsourcing payroll does not remove responsibility, but it does significantly reduce compliance risk when managed correctly.
How This Fits with Payroll Services in London
Both in-house and outsourced payroll models fall under broader payroll services in London. Many businesses start in-house and transition to outsourced or managed payroll as they grow.
Understanding the pros and cons helps ensure payroll support evolves in line with business needs.
A Practical Next Step for London Employers
If payroll is becoming time-consuming or error-prone, it may be worth reviewing whether in-house payroll is still the right approach.
BOOK YOUR FREE PAYROLL CHECKUP HERE!
Many London businesses explore outsourced payroll to gain reliability, compliance support, and peace of mind, without losing visibility or control.
